Davis & Co All articles
Contracts & Risk

Two Signatures, No Safety Valve: Reviewing Your Shareholder Arrangement Before It Is Tested

Davis & Co
Two Signatures, No Safety Valve: Reviewing Your Shareholder Arrangement Before It Is Tested

Most owner-managed companies are governed by a mixture of documents and memory. The articles sit in a file at Companies House, an accountant holds a copy of the incorporation paperwork, and the real arrangement — who decides what, how profits are split, what happens if one party wants out — lives in a conversation that took place years ago. That arrangement is comfortable while everyone agrees. It becomes expensive the moment they do not.

A shareholder agreement is not a sign of distrust. It is the mechanism that allows two people to disagree commercially without the disagreement becoming personal, procedural or litigious. With the year-end approaching and many companies reviewing their governance alongside their accounts, this is a sensible moment to test whether your arrangement would survive a serious fall-out.

What the Default Position Actually Gives You

Where there is no bespoke agreement, the relationship is governed by the Companies Act 2006, the company's articles and, in most small companies, the model articles. Those provisions do a competent job of the basics: they allow directors to make decisions collectively, permit share transfers in defined circumstances and set out how meetings are run.

What they do not do is resolve a genuine impasse. The model articles are largely silent on what happens when the board cannot reach a decision, and they say nothing at all about valuation, exit or the expectations shareholders may legitimately hold of one another. In a company with a single controlling shareholder this rarely matters. In a company split evenly between two owner-managers, it matters a great deal.

The statutory fallback is section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, which allows a shareholder to petition the court on the ground that the company's affairs have been conducted in a manner unfairly prejudicial to their interests. It is a real remedy and it occasionally works. It is also slow, public and costly, and the outcome is decided by a judge applying general principles to facts that were never written down. A well-drafted agreement exists to keep that scenario in the file marked 'unlikely'.

Deadlock: Designing the Way Out Before You Need It

The classic owner-managed structure — two directors, 50 per cent each, both drawing salaries — has no built-in tie-breaker. If the board divides on a significant decision, the company simply stops. Suppliers notice, staff notice, and the bank notices.

An agreement should set out an escalation route in advance. A typical sequence runs as follows: a formal notice of disagreement, a defined period for senior-level discussion, referral to mediation, and then a determinate mechanism — expert determination on a valuation question, or a buy-sell provision under which one party names a price and the other elects either to buy at that price or to sell at it. These mechanisms are uncomfortable to design and far less uncomfortable than discovering, mid-dispute, that no exit route exists.

Share Transfers: Who May Buy, and at What Price

A common misunderstanding concerns pre-emption. The statutory pre-emption rights in the Companies Act 2006 apply to the allotment of new shares, not to the transfer of existing ones. Unless the articles or a separate agreement restrict transfers, a shareholder may be able to sell to a third party in circumstances the other shareholder would find unacceptable.

A robust agreement deals with four questions. First, whether transfers require board or shareholder consent. Second, whether existing shareholders have a right of first refusal, and the timetable for exercising it. Third, how compulsory transfer is triggered — death, incapacity, serious breach, cessation of employment — and whether the departing party is treated as a good leaver or a bad leaver. Fourth, and most often overlooked, the valuation basis: a multiple of earnings, net asset value, or a formula, together with who appoints the valuer and whether that person acts as an expert rather than an arbitrator. Leaving the price to be agreed later is, in practice, leaving it to be litigated.

Board Control: The Reserved Matters List

Day-to-day decisions belong with the directors. The questions worth writing down are the ones that change the shape of the company: borrowing above a stated threshold, granting security, appointing or removing directors, issuing shares, changing the nature of the business, entering related-party transactions, declaring dividends, or selling the company.

A reserved matters schedule sets out which of these require unanimous consent or a specified majority. It should be short enough to be workable and specific enough to be enforceable, and it should be mirrored in the articles so that a third party dealing with the company cannot rely on the absence of an internal restriction.

Exit Mechanics and the Interaction With the Articles

Drag-along provisions allow a majority to require a minority to sell on the same terms; tag-along provisions protect a minority by allowing them to join a sale. Both are standard, and both should be drafted with the same care as the valuation clause, since a drag-along at an unattractive price is little comfort to the party being dragged.

The agreement should also require that the articles be amended to reflect its terms, and that no amendment be made to either document without consent. Where the company has a bank facility, an investor on the register, or a live share scheme, the agreement must be checked against those documents — a shareholders' agreement that conflicts with a subscription agreement creates exactly the uncertainty it was meant to remove.

A Year-End Checklist

Bringing the Document Up to Date

The purpose of this exercise is not to anticipate betrayal. It is to make sure that a commercial disagreement stays commercial. Most owner-managers who commission an agreement never need the deadlock clause or the buy-sell mechanism — but they benefit from having settled, in calmer conditions, the questions that would otherwise be settled by whichever party is prepared to spend more on lawyers.

This article is general guidance rather than legal advice. Shareholder arrangements turn on the specific facts of each company, and any revision should be prepared or reviewed by a solicitor instructed on those facts.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Notice Date in the Bottom Drawer: Auditing UK Business Energy Contracts in 2026

The Notice Date in the Bottom Drawer: Auditing UK Business Energy Contracts in 2026

Registered in Name Only: A 2026 Trade Mark Audit for UK Directors

Registered in Name Only: A 2026 Trade Mark Audit for UK Directors

Notice, Evidence, Escalation: The 2026 Playbook for a January 2027 Price Increase

Notice, Evidence, Escalation: The 2026 Playbook for a January 2027 Price Increase